COMMENTARY:
SCRAPBOOKING, OR MEMORY?
Could we please replace the term scrapbooking with memory?
Here's why: memory greatly expands the possibilities of what we are,
the products we make and sell, and the services we can offer. It
will help us appeal to a wider audience.
Not every customer wants to put all of her photos in an album.
She may want to frame some of them, turn them into an iron-on and
attach them to clothing, or use them in jewelry.
And not all of her memories are photographs. My prize possession
as a kid was a home-run ball hit by my idol, Minnie Minoso, of the
Chicago White Sox. It wouldn't fit in an album, but would have
looked nice in a shadow box or memory box.
If there was one thing I could point to that caused most
cross-stitch specialty shops to fail, it was their narrow, rigid
definition of needlework. Let's not make the same mistake again.
Branching into cardmaking and other forms of paper crafting is a
start, but only a start.
NEW COLUMNS THIS ISSUE
Kate's
Collage. Details of two great causes: A) Coats
& Clark's project to provide scarves for the athletes and
volunteers at the Special Olympics Winter Games in Idaho, and B) the
online auction of fabulous knit and crochet items made by the
industry's top designers – with proceeds benefiting the Rwanda
Knits project.
"Vinny Da Vendor". Below is an update on crooks
– scammers – who are trying to bilk small businesses. Here's the
original example send by a vendor.
Scene & Heard. Ellie Joos reports on the highlights
and the trends at the recent New York International Gift Show.
(Note: If a column appears to be something other than
what's described above, click on the Reload or Refresh button on
your browser.)
TAKE THE CLN POLL: READING CLN
How do you read CLN? Do you go to the site and read
it online? Or do you print the issue and read a hard copy? Are you
reading more online these days, and reading less hard-copy material?
CLN and no doubt many publishers want to know if your reading
habits have changed. To vote, click on Industry Polls in the
right-hand column or click HERE. (Reminder: If you want a
hard copy, click on Printer Version and then print. The printer
version has much wider margins, so you'll save paper and ink.)
CLN
POLL: A TOUGH SEASON AHEAD
The industry is not very optimistic about the coming Fall/Holiday
season. A mere 3.2% believe their profits will increase
substantially over 2007, and 16.1% predict profits will be
"somewhat" better than last year. On the other end of the
spectrum, 12.9% think their business will be much worse in terms of
profits, and a whopping 48.4% predict their profits will be
"somewhat" worse. The remaining 19.4% believe their
business will be about the same.
JO-ANN CUTS LOSSES
For the second quarter ended Aug. 2, the company had a net loss
of $11.7 million ($0.47/share) versus a net loss of $18.4 million
($0.76) a year ago. Operating loss for the second quarter was $16.5
million versus a $26.2 million loss for the prior year’s second
quarter. Net sales rose 3.7% to $403.0 million, and same-store sales
increased 3.3% compared with a 7.0% increase for the same period
last year.
Those are the overall figures. Jo-Ann’s sewing business, which
accounts for 51% of the overall sales, rose 4.5% on a same-store
sales basis. The craft business – 49.1% of total sales – had a
same-store sales increase of 1.3%. Sales in the large-format stores
rose 3.1% to $209.0 million, and same-store sales increased 2.3%,
compared with an increase of 9.2% a year ago. Small-format stores'
sales increased 0.6% to $186.9 million, and same-store sales rose
4.4% compared with a 4.8% increase in 2007.
The stock jumped 12% the morning after the earnings announcement
and conference call with analysts, and the securities firm Soleil-Stein
Research upgraded its rating to Buy from Hold.
For the first two quarters of the fiscal year, overall sales rose
4.5% to $849.1 million, and same-store sales increased 3.9%.
Large-format stores' sales rose 4.1% to $439.2, and same-store sales
were up 2.8%. Small-format stores' increased 1.0% to $394.6 million
from $390.6 million, and same-store sales were up 5.2%.
Chair/President/CEO Darrell Webb said, "I am proud of our
team for delivering another quarter of significant earnings
improvement in this challenging economic environment. Our balance
sheet continues to grow stronger each quarter, with improving cash
flow, lower inventory levels, and reductions in debt. While the
economic environment remains uncertain, I am confident that by
continuing to revitalize our stores, while keeping a tight focus on
expenses and inventories, we will not only weather this economic
downturn, but strengthen our competitive position in both crafts and
sewing."
During a conference call with analysts Webb said "Our team
continues to bring in better quality, better looking, and more
compelling fall seasonal merchandise. I think fall looks a lot
better compared to fall a year ago," Home Textiles Today reported.
But Webb expressed reservations regarding seasonal and home dec
merchandise because of the economy.
Gross margins improved to 47.6% from 45.7% due to lower sales of
clearance merchandise. Selling, general and administrative expenses
were $191.6 million, compared to $188.1 million a year ago, but they
improved to 47.5% of net sales from 48.4%, due to expense leverage
from the increase in sales and cost control efforts.
During the quarter, Jo-Ann opened three large-format stores and
closed one, and closed six small-format stores. Year-to-date, the
company has opened three large-format stores and closed two
large-format and seven small-format stores. Jo-Ann remodeled 11
stores in the quarter and year-to-date, has remodeled 22 stores, of
which four were enlarged from a small-format to a large-format
layout. For fiscal 2009, the company expects to open 21 new stores
and close approximately 30 stores, remodel 25, and transition five
from a small-format to a large-format layout. The current store
count is 201 large-format and 567 small-format stores.
MICHAELS' LOSSES DECLINE
Michaels' net loss for the second quarter ended Aug. 2 was $25
million compared a $44 million loss for the same quarter last year.
Fiscal year to date, the loss was $45 million compared to a $67
million loss a year ago.
Net sales for the quarter increased 1.0% to $796 million, but
same-store sales declined 2.6%. The decline in same-store sales was
caused by a 1.0% decline in the average ticket and a 1.6% decrease
in transactions. Sales for the year-to-date period are up 1.0% to
$1.643 billion, but same-store sales are down 2.8%. That decline was
due to a 2.2% decrease in transactions, a 0.4% decrease in average
ticket, and a 0.2% decrease in custom frame deliveries. A favorable
Canadian currency translation offset the decline in average ticket
by approximately 0.5% for the second quarter and approximately 0.8%
year to date.
Michaels' bonds fell sharply the following morning. Its 10%
senior notes due 2014 traded at about 74 cents on the dollar,
according to S&P, and its 11.375% notes due 2016 were trading at
about 63.5 cents on the dollar Monday, Financial Week reported.
CEO Brian Cornell said, "Overall, the soft economic
environment continues to adversely affect the business, particularly
with respect to certain high-ticket discretionary items and
home-related categories. While a number of our product categories
performed well, such as Kids Crafts, Jewelry & Beadmaking, and
Bakeware, sales declines in home-related categories including
Floral, Home Décor, and Custom
Framing more than offset these increases on a comparable store
basis."
The gross margin rate fell from 36.8% to 34.9% in the quarter due
primarily to a decrease in merchandise margins and a deleveraging of
occupancy and distribution costs due to declining same-store sales.
Selling, general, and administrative expense in the second quarter
increased $4 million to $246 million, or as a percent of sales, to
30.9% compared to 30.7% a year ago. Year-to-date SGA expense
increased to 31.5% of sales from 30.6%.
Average inventory/Michaels store at the end of the quarter,
inclusive of distribution centers, was down 3.3% to $899,000, due to
reduced yarn inventories, ongoing benefits from the Hybrid
Distribution model, and lower inventory values associated with
direct sourcing efforts.
For the second quarter, adjusted EBITDA, a measure of cash flow,
declined approximately $17 million to $73 million, 9.2% of sales,
from $90 million, 11.4% of sales, a year ago. Year-to-date, adjusted
EBITDA declined to $170 million, 10.3% of sales, from $203 million,
12.5% of sales.
Long-term debt rose from $3.734 billion to $3.748 billion, but
interest expense was lower by $19 million and $37 million for the
quarter and first half, respectively, due to a lower average
interest rate on the company's floating-rate debt and lower average
debt levels.
The second half of the year is expected to be similar to the
first half. The earnings statement said, "Low consumer
confidence and increased economic volatility are expected to have a
continued adverse effect on the business for the remainder of the
year, causing the forecasting of future results with any level of
certainty to be difficult. However, we now expect the first half
trends for same-store sales, adjusted EBITDA, net income, and cash
flow from operations to continue for the second half."
During the first half of the fiscal year, Michaels opened 28 new
stores, relocated six, remodeled one, and closed two Aaron Brothers
stores.
Cornell added, "With the Halloween, Fall, and Holiday
seasons approaching, our focus will be squarely on the customer. Our
goal is to provide a compelling product assortment and excellent
execution in our stores while conservatively managing our expense
structure and inventory commitments. We will, however, continue to
invest time and resources towards our key strategic initiatives,
such as our consumer insight and category management programs, in
order to assure the long-term growth and success of the Michaels
brand."
The complete earnings report is available on Michaels' website, www.michaels.com.
RITZ BECOMES A BIGGER PLAYER IN MEMORY
Software from Lucidiom has been installed in Ritz
Camera stores that enable the stores to expand their
"memory" services and products. The company now offers a
one-hour photo book cover, proof books, note cards, and banners. The
covered photo book is a full-bleed jacket for 11"x8.5" and
8"x6" photo books. Customers can combine photos and text
or choose a photo-only jacket, and can personalize the inner flaps.
Proof books, which Ritz refers to as the customer’s "photo
library," are a photo archive and replace the traditional index
print. The photo library consists of unbound, double-sided sheets
with 9-12 photos per side, and is offered in four sizes. Folded note
cards, designed to have a photo on the front and a blank inside for
hand-written notes, are available in 10-packs. In addition to the
36"x12" and 30"x12" banners, the stores can now
offer 72"x24" banners that can be text/photos or
text-only.
Ritz Camera Centers is the largest specialty camera and image
chain in the U.S. with approximately 1,000 locations in 45 states
and the District of Columbia. The chain includes Ritz Camera, Wolf
Camera, Kits Camera, Inkley’s, and The Camera Shop. To see what
the stores offer, visit www.ritzpix.com.
Lucidiom's site is www.lucidiom.com.
HOW ONE INDEPENDENT IS BOOSTING SALES
(Note: The industry – and CLN – has been filled
with stories and complaints about slow sales. Here's an independent
who is bucking that trend.)
I have Scrapbook Village in Glasgow, KY. It's rural – a
farm and a lake area. Our sales slid in 2007, but we came up with
more features and ideas to keep customers traveling to the Village.
Our sales were up 7% in the first quarter and another 8% in the
second quarter.
We are very hopeful and won't let the doom-and-gloom reports take
us down! I read it all and pray a lot and do not want to go out of
business. Re-adjusting; creative, wonderful customer service; and
reading Kizer and Bender ALL THE TIME keep me focused and on
track.
We continue to have staff meetings, conduct surveys, and talk to
the customers to learn what they want and need. We try a major
weekend event to make up for a slow day during the week –
something old and something new. Check the website at www.scrapbookvillage.net
(not a good one, but it will show you some of the different events).
Georganne [Bender] would tell you "we like food" and we
have lots of it at every event. We just had a Fiesta, catered by a
Mexican restaurant, and it sold out. We had a PiZata
filled with scrapbook supplies, music, a crop, Fiesta bingo, and
door prizes from leftover products. Cost us almost nothing and
increased sales by four figures in one day. Fantastic for us.
Also, we've started to work with a local bed and breakfast for a
scrappers weekend; we're already sold out for three weekends – and
we haven't even started yet. Retreat weekends (separate from the
b&b) bring in $12,000 just on registration, not counting the
sales (another $10,000). We have them twice a year.
And each week I make contact with scrapbook clubs that are
popping up everywhere in churches. I invite them to a free crop,
offer a nice make-it/take-it, and refreshments – and give them a
bounce-back coupon. My email list grows each time and I have at
least two new ones a month. Word spreads and my business increases.
Get them in the store and we all win.
This summer I serve lemonade and cookies; the men have a waiting
area with a tv and a refrigerator with free drinks. (All ideas were
taken from Kizer and Bender – great, aren't they!)
We also started a Bible study group and it is awesome. After
hours, to not be disturbed, prayer-and-share scripture scrapbooking,
and on and on.
My website is not the best, but the backroom tells me consumers
are opening it often. My sight doesn't offer online sales, just
information about the "happiest place to be."
Women need relationships and that is what we have building here,
as always.
Oh, and we've raised our prices and no one has complained.
– Bonnie Wilcome
(Note: Anyone else have positive news to report? Let CLN
know what it is and how you achieved it. Email your thoughts to mike@clnonline.com.
Rich Kizer and Georganne Bender's website is www.kizerandbender.com.)
THE SCAMMERS KEEP TRYING
In "Vinny Da Vendor" a manufacturer described how he
had been approached by a retailer supposedly in Australia who wanted
to place an order. Now the vendor reports he's receiving similar
emails from "stores" in Japan and Spain. He traced one
that originated from a server in Columbus, OH. Here's the latest
example:
(Note: The spelling and punctuation are left as is.)
"Hello, Our company name is MOORE INVESTMENT INC. We will like
to order some of your products to our store in Tokyo Japan, Do you
ship to Japan ? If NOT there is this courier service that have
shipped for us before and their service is very good, fast, reliable
and secured.But before we proceed with the order, we will like to
know the type of credit card you accept in your company cos.our mode
of payment will be via credit card. Have a wonderful day as we await
your quick response."
Even CLN has been approached by scammers. This unedited
email arrived last week: "Sales, Am Frank George from Germany,I
browse through your contact and I found some interested items,I want
to know if you can ship direct to germany or if you can ship to my
freight forwarder in U.S, I also want to know the cost per product
and if you do accept credit card payment e.g master card or visa
card. I await your fast response so I can proceed with my needed
items and quantity. Best Regards. Frank George."
Another recent scam: A "travel/event" company is
contacting CHA members saying CHA's blocks of hotel rooms for
the Anaheim show in February are sold out, but this company has
rooms available, so make reservations with a credit card through
this company.... Although CHA rooms are being snapped up more
quickly than they were a year ago, plenty of rooms are still
available at CHA-negotiated rates and on the CHA shuttle bus routes.
To see the list of available rooms, visit www.chashow.org
and click on "Show Info," then "Hotel &
Travel."
PHOTO PRODUCTS FOR RETAILERS
ScrapBiz is offering a new program, PhotoBookBiz. The
wholesale Photobook Biz program is supported by Visan
Industries, the creators of Rocket Life (www.rocketlife.com).
Visan provides the creative software plug-in, product printing, and
fulfillment, while ScrapBiz provides the business support and
marketing materials.
"The scrapbook industry has changed rapidly in the last five
years," said ScrapBiz founder Kim Guymon. "Digital
scrapbooking and photo books have become very popular ways to
preserve your memories. The majority of scrapbookers have digital
cameras and for some of them, it makes more sense to print a photo
book rather than individual photos. Retailers in the traditional
scrapbook industry have struggled to figure out how to capitalize on
this trend. The PhotoBookBiz Program is that answer to that
question."
Retailers can offer their customers photo products such as mugs,
calendars, cards, and collages in addition to the photo books.
"The plug-in or creative platform used to make these products
is very user friendly yet innovative," said Guymon. "Visan's
exclusive 'Smart Arrangement Technology' makes creating a beautiful
product or book easy for anyone who knows how to click and
drag."
Currently, the program is only available to ScrapBiz members but
will be launched this October to all retailers in the scrapbook
industry. Interested retailers may sign up at www.scrapbiz.com.
THE U.S. JUSTICE SYSTEM AT WORK
In January 2006, former Vice Chair of Wal-Mart Tom
Coughlin pled guilty to five counts of wire fraud and one count of
tax evasion. He had been accused of having employees manipulate
employee-travel-reimbursement and vendor-invoice accounting systems
to embezzle money, gift cards, and products for his personal
benefit.
Although he pled guilty to six felony charges, Coughlin was
sentenced to five years' probation, with 27 of the months on home
detention, plus 1,500 hours of community service. He was also
ordered to pay a $50,000 fine, $306,822. 40 in restitution to
Wal-Mart, and $104,395.60 to the IRS.
Wal-Mart, understandably, voided Coughlin's retirement package
worth $17 million, since he had pled guilty of misappropriating
hundreds of thousands of company dollars and caused a public
relations nightmare.
Coughlin sued and recently settled with the company. Now he will
only receive $6.75 million, according to the Northwest Arkansas
News. (Comment. Sure glad the IRS got that extra 60
cents. Now we don't have to worry about the federal deficit.)
EMAIL: A VENDOR COMPLAINS OF CHARGEBACKS
It is kinda frustrating to see chains increasing deductions from
vendor compliance with no proof to validate their claims. They will
just deduct regardless. I started seeing vendor compliance
deductions from a chain we have been doing business with for a long
time using the same routing guide. I see a drop in sales reports,
and I could not help thinking, is this a way to maybe get something
to offset the drop in sales?
I wonder if they ever read about the lawsuit with a well known
chain of stores regarding chargebacks. I just wish there were rules
to govern these types of invalid deductions. – Name Withheld
RANDOM NOTES, RANDOM THOUGHTS
1. A book publisher is looking for industry companies who
have gone "green." CLN has profiled the efforts of
some companies – Duncan, Walnut Hollow, Plaid,
and Mrs. Grossman's, to name a few. But I hope there are
others, too. If your business has gone green, let me know and I'll
pass along the info to the publisher.
2. The Martha Stewart products are in Wal-Mart
now, and the retailer's approach is much different than the way Michaels
merchandises her products. There is no special sign, and the
products are not grouped together; some are in the wedding aisle and
others are in scrapbooking. It does not appear that Wal-Mart
expanded its overall craft department to add Martha's goodies, which
means some vendors probably lost space to make room. But like the
products in Michaels, Martha's SKU's seem pricey.
3. For independents who think it's probably easier to
operate a chain rather than an individual store, look at the list of
recent retail bankruptcies: Boscov's, Mervyns, Steve & Barry's,
Linens 'n Things, and Sharper Image.
4. As the economy stalls, some retailers are adding
seemingly unusual product lines to their inventory, thinking
gas-conscious consumers will do more one-store shopping. Best Buy
has started selling musical instruments, Walgreens added a clothing
line, and Menards is selling frozen pizza. Makes you wonder if
non-industry stores out there might, for the first time, be
interested in selling scrapbook and kids craft supplies.
MISCELLANEOUS NEWS
AWARDS. At Michaels' recent 12th annual CEO Summit,
the company gave Vendor Partnership of the Year awards to Crayola,
Horizon Group USA, and me & my BIG ideas. Carrier
of the Year awards were given to APL Limited and Con-way
Truckload.
CORRECTION. The previous issue quoted a retailer who said
she was told by a Hobby Lobby manager that the chain was
discontinuing single sheets of cardstock and printed paper. Not
true, HL's Randy Green told CLN. "In fact, our stores
are just now receiving many new styles that we are excited about and
believe that our customers will be, too," Randy said.
GOOD WORKS. Family Circle's Sept. issue profiled
Linda Swinford, who started Operation Helmet Liner – volunteers
knitting helmet liners for U.S. soldiers fighting in the Afghan/Iraq
winter, and neck coolers for the summer. The operation has shipped
60,000+ items to soldiers. For more info, including the pattern for
the correct size helmet liner, visit www.geocities.com/helmetliner.
NEEDLEWORK. Sept. 10 is the deadline for applications to
host an intern in The National NeedleArts Assn.'s Pathways
into Professional Needlearts program. Visit www.tnna.org.
WEARABLE ART. Technology has hit the category. The shoe
company, Keds, will make a custom pair of shoes for customers who
have uploaded photos and images and chosen from a selection of
patterns and colors at www.keds.com.
... A new store, Fashionology L.A. opened in Beverly Hills this
summer. It's an interactive make-your-own clothing shop designed for
teen and tween girls who use a touch-screen display to choose
illustrations, crystals, pins, chains, etc., for sweatshirts,
t-shirts, and even dresses. Then the item is made for the customer
in the store while she waits. Visit www.fashionologyla.com.
SHOWS. Interweave Press' Bead Fest in Philadelphia
last month had a unique feature, a "Bead Slam" in which
entrants had five hours and a room full of beads to create a piece
of jewelry, while the audience cheered them on. The first 100
projects were critiqued for technique and creativity by judges, and
the 20 finalists advanced to the final round. There were prizes for
the top three winners, and the first prize winner, Diane
Worthington, will be featured in the 2008 Bead Star magazine.
The "Bead Slam" was sponsored by Fire Mountain Gems and
Beadalon.
PEOPLE. Jerry Bowman was promoted from VP of Sales to
President of Spellbinders Paper Arts. Prior to Spellbinders
he worked for Bazzill Basics Paper and Xyron. In 2006
Jerry founded the Christian Missions & Outreach (www.cmo-info.org),
a non-profit foundation that builds/manages orphanages and supports
prison and homeless ministries in Guadalajara, Mexico. MARTHA. Martha
Stewart Living Omnimedia announced most U.S. and Canadian Wal-Mart
stores are now selling Martha's scrapbooks, jewelry-making kits and
other craft products – almost 400 SKU's. Martha continues to
expand her licensing deals because her largest deal, towels and
other home products at Sears/Kmart, expires in 2010, and guaranteed
royalty payments from that deal fall from $65 million this year to
an estimated $20 million next year, the Wall Street Journal reported.
AUDIO. Knitting out Loud has released two new audio books,
KnitKnit: Profiles + Projects From Knitting's New Wave by
Sabrina Gschwandtner read by the author, and Knitting Lessons:
Tales From the Knitting Path by Lela Nargi read by Julia Olson.
Interweave Press will distribute the books. For more info, visit www.knittingoutloud.com
and www.interweave.com/books/default.asp.
WORKSHOPS. CHA extended the deadline for sponsoring a
workshop at the Winter Show until this Fri., Sept. 5. Visit www.chashow.org
to download the application form. For more info, email Avery Dykman
at adykman@craftandhobby.org
or call 201-835-1204.
REPS NEEDED. A manufacturer of embellishments for paper
crafting needs reps in Northern CA, UT, AZ, CO, WY, KS, Northeast
U.S. Email mchiu@creativecharms.com.
STOCKS. A.C. Moore: $8.08, up $0.01 ... Jo-Ann: $24.15, up
$2.38 ... Wal-Mart: $59.37, up $1.62 ... Dow Jones: 11,659.90, up
2.9%. CLN will now resume reporting on Hancock's stock now
that the company has emerged from bankruptcy. The stock trades under
the symbol HKFI and closed Friday at $1.45. (Note: All
changes in price are since 8/15 and are exclusive of dividends.)
THE CREATIVE NETWORK: JOB OPENINGS
To see the latest listings by the only personnel recruitment firm
specializing in our industry, click on Jobs in the left-hand column
or click HERE.
LAWS OF ULTIMATE REALITY, PT II
Law of Biomechanics: The severity of the itch is inversely
proportional to the reach.
Law of the Theater: At any event, the people whose seats
are furthest from the aisle arrive last.
The Starbucks Law: As soon as you sit down to a cup of hot
coffee, your boss will ask you to do something which will last until
the coffee is cold.
Murphy's Law of Lockers: If there are only two people in a
locker room, they will have adjacent lockers.
Law of Physical Surfaces: The chances of an open-faced
jelly sandwich landing face down on a floor covering are directly
correlated to the newness and cost of the carpet/rug.
Law of Logical Argument: Anything's possible if you don't
know what you're talking about.
Brown's Law of Physical Appearance: If the shoe fits, it's
ugly.
Oliver's Law of Public Speaking: A closed mouth gathers no
feet.
Wilson's Law of Commercial Marketing Strategy: As soon as
you find a product that you really like, they will stop making it.
Doctor' Law: If you don't feel well, make an appointment
to go to the doctor, and by the time you get there you'll feel
better. Don't make an appointment and you'll stay sick.
REMINDERS
1. If you want a hard-copy of this issue, click on
"Printer Friendly version."
2. If your company is a paid subscriber, everyone in the main
office is welcome to register, free. Just click on "Work for a
paid subscriber? Click Here to register" (center column, near
the top).
3. If you ever have trouble with your password, click on
"Trouble with your password" in the right-hand column of
the main page. The computer will then email the correct information
to you.
4. Creative Leisure News is published the first and third Mondays of each month.
Consequently, your next issue will be Monday, September 15. Happy
Labor Day!