Home
Business-Wise
Kate's Collage
"Vinny Da Vendor"
"Benny Da Buyer"
Kizer & Bender
Memory, Paper & Stamps
Category Reports
Designing Perspectives
Scene & Heard


Creative Leisure News
306 Parker Circle
Lawrence, KS 66049
Phone: 785-760-5071
Email: mike@clnonline.com


 


Challenges, problems, and triumphs -- from a manufacturer's perspective.

Printer Version

Some Thoughts on Bankruptcy

It's unfair, but ....

by Mike Hartnett (January 7, 2008)

Junkitz filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy liquidation just before Christmas, and once again I've received complaints from suppliers venting about the unfairness of it all. I've written a lot about bankruptcy over the years and I've never figured out if the bankruptcy laws make sense or could be improved.

Retailers close their doors without paying vendors and vendors walk away leaving their suppliers in the lurch. Banks and credit card companies loan money to consumers and encourage them to spend, spend, spend, then scream when those customers are bankrupt.

And it's not just small companies. Rag Shop was a major chain in the East; a couple of years ago it told its vendors if they didn't take 25 cents on the dollar as payment, the company would shut down like Junkitz. The vendors reluctantly agreed, saving Rag Shop about $8 million. Then 14 months later Rag Shop shut down anyway, and this time vendors will probably get nothing.

1. It's unfair to creditors. Absolutely no question about that, but look at the larger picture: keeping a company afloat saves jobs. When Ames was in Chapter 11 (reorganization), it was reported that by staying in business, Ames was keeping as many as 10,000 people employed.

But the articles never checked to see how many employees of Ames' vendors were laid off because Ames only paid pennies on the dollar.

Ames emerged from bankruptcy, then went bankrupt again a few years later. This time it closed its doors and eventually led to the demise of Craft World, once the industry's largest distributor, whom Ames stiffed for $1.3 million.

2. Secured creditors and lawyers. It's unfair that they get paid in full before the unsecured creditors (the vendors) receive a penny. But stop and think: banks wouldn't loan money if they weren't assured they'd be first in line when a business fails.

The bankruptcy laws, like so many other laws, are endlessly complicated. No bankruptcy case would ever be resolved without lawyers, and no lawyer would take a case if he thought he wouldn't be paid.

Years ago when I was editor of Craftrends, I was asked to serve on the unsecured creditors committee for a large industry company, which owed Craftrends for some advertising. I thought serving on the committee would be interesting and agreed. It took an enormous amount of time, mostly conference calls, but what truly shocked me was the amount of paperwork. It seemed like any time someone sneezed, a lawyer would send us a report. By the time the case was resolved, I had a stack of paper almost a foot tall.

Bottom line: Craftrends received virtually nothing.

Occasionally a CLN subscriber has declared bankruptcy and listed CLN as a creditor because the company owed for its subscription. Then I receive letters from the court about the case. I'm sure it cost more for a lawyer to send me those letters than it would have been to pay for the subscription in the first place.

3. The 90-day payback is unfair. A portion of the law requires any vendor who received a payment within 90 days of the bankruptcy filing should pay that money back to the bankrupt company, even if the creditor is still owed thousands or millions.

Here's the rationale: Suppose I have a business that's not going well and I'm afraid I'll end up in bankruptcy. I have a vendor, Vendor A, who is a good friend and I don't want to see him hurt any worse than possible. So I pay him what I can, and ignore Vendors B, C, and D. Then I file for bankruptcy. That's human nature, but is it fair?

So every creditor is supposed to return any payments received during that 90-day period. Then the court collects all that money, sells the company's assets, and then divides it among all of the creditors.

That's fair, but the poor vendor who was owed $10,000, received $50 prior to the bankruptcy, then received a letter from a lawyer demanding the vendor pay back the $50. "It's like they stick the knife in with the bankruptcy," one exasperated manufacturer told CLN, "then they twist the knife demanding the money back."

Meanwhile, the lawyer probably charged the court $50 to write the letter.

Years ago I wrote a column about the 90-day requirement and received a panicked phone call from a small vendor who somehow had received a payment from a chain in trouble. "If I have to pay that back, I'll lose my house," she said.

The chain hung on a few months longer before filing for bankruptcy, so the vendor's house was saved. Later the vendor sold her company, which today is one of the leading brands in its category.

So, any ideas about how to improve our bankruptcy laws? Email your thoughts to CLN at mike@clnonline.com. I'm all ears.

(Note: To read previous Business-Wise entries, click on the title in the right-hand column.)

xxx

 

horizontal rule

horizontal rule



   
   

Vinny's Recent Columns...
ADVICE ON EXPORTING TO THE UK AND EUROPE; An interview with the former CEO of HobbyCraft.

THE HISTORY OF WALNUT HOLLOW; One of the genuine pioneers of the modern craft industry.

HOW MICHIGAN SCRAPBOOKER WAS LAUNCHED; Substantial growth in 3+ years.

THE HISTORY OF PLAID ENTERPRISES, INC.; It's come a long way in 36 years.

"FLASH" SALES COME TO THE INDUSTRY; Q. & A. about the newest way to introduce new products or dispose of overstocks.

SITTING ON A BULLS EYE; What to do if competitors want your market share, or customers want to cut costs.

IS YOUR COMPANY ON THE VERGE OF BANKRUPTCY? 5 SURVIVAL TIPS; Time for a reality check.

FIVE COMMON AFFLICTIONS OF SALES TEAMS; The result: Bad morale and lower sales.

BEYOND MARKET MULTIPLES: INCREASING THE VALUE OF YOUR COMPANY BEFORE THE SALE; How to create a company with greater appeal to buyers.

CHA SHOW NEW PRODUCT REPORT; Hundreds (thousands?) of products, many from new exhibitors.

THE SOLUTION TO MEXICAN DRUG CARTELS; A sure fire way to inspire them to quilt.

ATTRACTING YOUNGER CUSTOMERS; Yes, we aren't our mothers' knitters.

NEW PRODUCTS TO BE UNVEILED AT THE CHAS SHOW; Two parts: new exhibitors and veterans.

WHAT SCRAPPERS ARE SAYING ABOUT MANUFACTURERS AND PUBLISHERS; Scrapbook Updates' readers analyze the problems.

ANALYZING THE CHA ATTITUDE & USAGE STUDY; The rationale and the science behind the number.

REST IN PEACE: JEAN HOWARD BARR; JHB International's Founder and CEO.

POSITIVE NEWS ABOUT THE INDUSTRY; What they want/need from the industry.

COMMENTS FROM INDIE CRAFTERS; What they want/need from the industry.

UNDERSTANDING INDIE CRAFTERS (BY AN INDIE CRAFTER); What they want, what they buy, and how to reach them.

CHA EVENTS FOR MANUFACTURERS; How to get more out of a trade show besides selling your products.

CREATIVE INDUSTRY TURNS TO EDUCATION TO BEAT RECESSION; Simple solutions for vendors and retailers to create online video classes.

WHAT HAPPENED TO CREATIVE MEMORIES? Not adjusting to the times.

COMPLAINING ABOUT SHORT-SHIPMENT PENALTIES; Who pays retail? The vendor?

HOW A VENDOR SCAMMED A SCAMMER; A sharp eye, a sense of humor - and be wary.

HOW A SMALL VENDOR WAS ALMOST SCAMMED; A savvy, suspicious mind averted a serious financial loss.

COMPANY FOR SALE; The owner is retiring.

EXHIBITORS: YOU'RE WASTING YOUR MONEY! Check your customer list before pre-show mailings.

PLAID CONSERVES TO PRESERVE; Simple changes can mean big savings.

SUGGESTIONS FOR THE CHA SHOW; How to attract more buyers and exhibitors.

CHANGES AT A.C. MOORE; They may not be what they seem.

THE TERRI O SHOW IS COMING; Building industry sales by empowering consumers' creativity.

SOME THOUGHTS ON BANKRUPTCY; It's unfair, but...

BOTTLES OF HOPE; A polymer clay grassroots movement.

SEWING SMILES FOR KIDS; Pillowcases and quilts for kids in hospitals.

HELPING THE WORLD IN MORE WAYS THAN ONE; Mrs. Grossman's, C&T Publishing, and Tara Materials.

HELP PEOPLE -- AND THE WORLD; How one company contributes to charities and to Mother Nature.

TAKING CARE OF BUSINESS AND HELPING THE WORLD; Plaid employees' long list of charitable activities.

A SAVVY WAY TO INTRODUCE A NEW LINE; Put it in the hands of consumers and teachers.

CHA AND PMA: SHOULD IT BE EITHER/OR? Why not take the best of both worlds?

A VENDOR'S RESPONSE TO THE PROVO/CRICUT ISSUEE; It's not easy to take sides.

RESPONSES TO CLN'S CODE OF ETHICS...from chain store execs, vendors, and reps.

PROVO RESPONDS TO CRICUT CRITICS; Unexpected demand caused problems.

ADVICE TO VENDORS; Common sense, please!

HOW TO HAVE A GREAT TRADE SHOW; It takes more than great products.

KEY CHALLENGES/OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE CRAFT INDUSTRY IN 2006; Office supply, private label, and direct import.

IS MIKE DUPEY RIGHT? The industry's retail pioneer's criticism of chain stores elicits strong reactions.

RETAILERS: CREATE A "PLACE," NOT A STORE; Customers return if they feel a sense of community.

"HOW AND WHY WE CHANGED OUR BUSINESS"; Sometimes necessity forces gutsy businesses into new, scary areas.

WHY INDEPENDENTS ARE DECLINING AND THE INDUSTRY IS SOFT; We can't improve the situation until we understand the causes.

HOW TO MAKE THE SCRAPBOOK PIE LARGER; "Keep it simple and non-threatening."

INDEPENDENTS: SUPPORT VENDORS WHO SUPPORT YOU; "Support goes both ways. It is a relationship of trust and consistency."

WHAT MAKES A GREAT SALES REP? Colleagues and customers remember the late Bob Watikins.

TRADE SHOW PRESS POINTERS; Maximize your publicity for a minimal cost.

HOW CAN A SCRAPBOOK START-UP SUCCEED? The answer may be a "Group" away.

DO TRADE SHOWS REFLECT THE STATE OF THE INDUSTRY? If we're like other industries, trade shows may be in trouble.

DO TRADE SHOWS REFLECT THE STATE OF THE INDUSTRY? And if so, are we in trouble?

THE STATE OF THE FLORAL MARKET; A blunt interview with Aldik's Larry Gold.

YOU WANT JUNK? YOU GOT IT; Pricing pressures are ruining good categories.

PLANNING THE PERFECT TRADE SHOW; Ten tips for CHA Winter Show exhibitors.

MORE VENDORS RESPOND...; A dialog between vendors and a savvy but unhappy independent.

VENDORS RESPOND TO INDEPENDENT'S PLIGHT; Why vendors have minimums and what retailers can do about it.

RETAIL, E-TAIL, AND "UNFAIR COMPETITION"; Expensive advertising, false promises, and little education.

THE TRIALS OF A SMALL COMPANY, PT. II; Expensive advertising, false promises, and little education.

THE TRIALS OF A SMALL COMPANY; Talent, drive, and product -- but no money.

GETTING READY FOR A TRADE SHOW; Go MAD at HIA.

THE THREE L's: YOU CAN'T SELL WITHOUT THEM; How to look, listen, and learn.

IT WASN'T ALWAYS THIS WAY...; but why does that matter?

WHATEVER HAPPENED TO STRAWBERRY?; Does every new product have to be cheap?